Kazigor Several months ago I found the entire book Disputers of the Dao and bought it immediately. It is therefore very frustrating to find Lightman concluding that the credibility and popularization of agnosticism did not survive the disputsrs of the Victorian age by the new physics and by the revolt against positivism. Now we are in a world of images. Disputers of the Tao: Philosophical Argument in Ancient China Garlanded with tributes even before publication, it has redrawn the map of its subject and will be the one essential guide for any future exploration.

Author:Malashura Arashirisar
Language:English (Spanish)
Published (Last):17 May 2015
PDF File Size:5.72 Mb
ePub File Size:19.42 Mb
Price:Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]

There are 40 dedicated to the Chuang Tzu, and the last half of the book has little to say about Tao. One point of interest in this book is that Mr.

Whereas the writings of Confucius are datable closer to BCE, we can be fairly confident that the Tao Te Ching was the work of various authors that was complied a bit Disputers of the Tao - A. Whereas the writings of Confucius are datable closer to BCE, we can be fairly confident that the Tao Te Ching was the work of various authors that was complied a bit earlier than BCE although most of the ideas predate this period.

Since this book was published we know the author was wrong about the dating of the Lao Tzu. And although current information puts Mr. Many have preferred to fancy The Tao Te Ching as the oldest of and thus wisest of the ancient Chinese philosophies, and may be disturbed by this assertion, but the text in its entirety also benefited from the study of the philosophies that preceded it and thereby was able to hone its unique philosophy.

Let me take issue with what I regard as an important point made within this informative, well researched book: On page 84 of my Open Court paperback issue, Mr. Graham states, ". This implies an awareness of sense perception as problematic for which there is no firm evidence in China before the arrival of Buddhism.

Names able to be named Are not unchanging names. Lacking name, the ten thousand things are in potential. Naming, is mother of the ten thousand things. Therefore, eternally without desire accords with a view of essence. Having constant desire accords with a view off the surface. These two arise together yet are estranged by naming. In unity we speak to its abstruseness; Dark, it is in turn dark, All essence its gateway.

There is nothing wrong with this translation other than perhaps sounding vague to some, or worse, mystical. We cannot DEfinie INfinity without speaking of something less than infinity. Infinite reality, rather than personal reality, is the topic and it is represented rather than defined by the logo "Tao". Many authors before and since have defined Tao as "The Way" and have missed the point or, at least, muddied the waters for the reader.

The Tao Te Ching is asserting or reasserting a topic of debate while also broadening the parameters of the debate. This might sound complicated but the intent is to be clear and serve a practical purpose.

Words may be used to communicate, but the definiteness of our words AND sense perceptions, define our own reality so closely that we devalue reality beyond ourselves. So in order to be clear seeing and clear thinking, we need to devalue our personal viewpoints while valuing reality beyond our selves instead.

But we have an extremely difficult time with this because we value our point of view above a "broader view from infinity" so to speak. Now we are in a world of images. Both our rational viewpoints as well as our physical viewpoints are so definite that we call them "true". The Tao Te Ching implores us to get around this error of reason and view by imagining other views from a desire-less or non-personal perspective.

It represents a dark red color, the symbolic color of heaven. Because people near to us in space and time tend to share and reflect back to us the same physical and rational viewpoint, sheer numbers of local agreement make this perception seem broad and true rather than narrow and ignorant. This happens everyday, and with peoples that differ either in perspective or place on the globe, the conflicts caused by our misperceptions are enormous while they defend their views in the exact same way as we do.

Discussion of infinity demands we read the implications of visuals into the text in order to get past the limitations of the written word. The text and the visuals provided by the Chinese characters support this. There are other chapters, notably 10, 26, and 54 that address this issue too.


Disputers of the Tao: Philosophical Argument in Ancient China


3302 HSA PDF




Disputers of the Tao : philosophical argument in ancient China


Related Articles